#ef7e12

The Tyranny of Metrics

Cihan Demir // Allianz Türkiye – Agile Team Member

In business, we all rely on numbers the most. So, could measurement metrics be misleading us? How will creativity, motivation and courage grow as the metrics hang over our heads like Damocles' sword? The questions raised by The Tyranny of Metrics will be inspiring for all of us.

Is there a performance metric that encourages rather than blames, triggers innovation, sparks creativity, embraces all types of motivation, prioritizes what is important, does not use ways to cut corners, is sensitive to input/output balance, increases productivity, is proper for teamwork and is compatible with flexible working hours?

If a doctor’s performance were measured by the rate of successful surgery, wouldn't they avoid high-risk operations?

If a teacher’s performance were measured by students' test scores, wouldn't they shy away from asking difficult questions?

If an aggressive forward has a goal-scoring target, do they assist, or do they shoot at every opportunity?

If an academic's performance were dependent on only the number of articles they published, independent of journals and citations, what would be their intrinsic motivation to develop science?

If a software developer's performance were measured by the number of calls they solved, would their appetite for meeting difficult and time-consuming demands change?

Is the problem in the metrics or in the content of the metrics? Can we measure performance without these metrics? If we are not going to rely on data to maintain objectivity, what should we hope for?

Do the metrics we measure for added value, efficiency and performance improvement lead to the opposite or misleading results? Do manipulated metrics cause dysfunction in the organization for the sake of making performance look good?

When metrics are the basis of the punishment and reward system, do the processes or works become deformed and superficial? What do we give up so that the metric reaches the expected value? So, what will these renunciations cost in the future? When we say "it’s better than nothing," is it possible that we are creating debts in the future that will cause more loss than today's profit?

Our passion for making the unmeasurable things measurable through metrics seems problem-free to us. Could this be causing internal degradation? Contrary to what we expected, could the effect be negative rather than positive?

If we measure performance with a Taylorist approach in jobs that require creativity, ability and from time to time initiative despite being technical or routine office jobs, can we get value-added and high-productivity outputs, or will we have to settle for an average and targeted output?

Do we showcase extrinsic motivation through the performance metrics we create and store intrinsic motivation in storage? Can we maintain the balance of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation through metrics? Are those which are the easiest to measure actually the most important? Or does it require a different and more difficult approach to measure the most important ones? Or do we deviate from measuring the important ones?

Which one should we measure: The performance of inputs or processes such as resources, budgets, time, or the performance of product quality or outputs? So, do the metrics that we create by combining both sides push us to get average results? When trying to achieve a balance, do we get away from getting the result that really makes the difference?

How can we measure creativity, initiative, politeness, leadership, vision, cultural change through metrics? How can we convert qualitative to quantitative? Should we convert? To what extent do we sacrifice quality with quantitative measurement?

It is said that you can’t manage “what” you can't measure. So, what should this "what" be? What should it not be? Is it human or machine? Is it creativity or efficiency? Is it process or system? Or should we choose the ones we need and model them with our own tailor-made methods and create hybrid "things" to measure?

Creating metrics, tracking and setting and objective, measuring performance over them, constructing a penalty/reward system, controlling its effects and development from different points, revising, changing, eliminating or transforming them... It's not easy, and we can feel the sword of Damocles over our heads through the process.

Well, what shall we do? I leave you with the book "The Tyranny of Metrics" that prompted me to write and title this article. Published in 2018, the book by Jerry Z. Mueller, a retired professor and expert on the history of capitalism, not only does not tire or bore you with its fluent language, but also contains inspiring stories, makes you think creatively and take copious notes. Most importantly, it raises new questions in your mind, just like it did for me... I wish you a quiet time and a pleasant reading in the rush of the modern world...

P.S. You can contact us by clicking here to share your experiences and ask questions about the agile working method.
 

Tyranny of Metrics, Jerry Z. Mueller 

 

Comments

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.